Black in Magic: The Gathering has some of the most efficient and ruthless removal spells in the game—but not all are created equal, and not everyone belongs in your deck. Whether you’re gunning for tournament wins or just crushing your local pod, picking the right black spot removal can make or break your strategy.

This short guide breaks down the three key factors you need to weigh when choosing removal: how it fits your game plan, what threats you’re likely to face, and how it interacts with the rest of your cards. Do take note: make smarter cuts, land cleaner kills.

Choosing the best black spot removal for your Magic: The Gathering (MTG) deck depends first on your deck’s strategy and speed. If you’re running an aggressive deck, you’ll want cheap, instant-speed removal like Fatal Push or Disfigure to clear blockers early. A midrange or control deck can afford more expensive, versatile spells like Go for the Throat, Infernal Grasp, or even sweepers like Damnation or Toxic Deluge if it needs to reset the board. The key is matching the removal’s mana cost and timing to your deck’s curve and tempo.

Next, consider the metagame and what threats you’re expecting to face. If artifacts and indestructible creatures are common, Go for the Throat or Doom Blade won’t cut it. Despite the drawbacks, Anoint with Affliction or Hero’s Downfall might be better bets. If planeswalkers are an issue, prioritize spells that can hit them. Decks with graveyard recursion might demand exile effects like The End. Knowing what you’re up against helps avoid dead cards and ensures your removal solves the problems you’re facing on the battlefield.

Lastly, balance efficiency and card synergy. Some decks thrive with removal that feeds other cards—Bone Shards can help Madness or Reanimator decks, while Snuff Out is free in mono-black shells. If you’re running Sheoldred, the Apocalypse, or other creatures that want your opponent’s hand depleted, consider removal that also disrupts, like Liliana of the Veil. Always ask: Does this removal fit the deck’s overall plan, or is it just a generic answer? The best removal works with your deck, not just in it.

Thanks for reading and until the next blog post.