Ways to Determine the Best White Cards in a Newly-Released Set

Posted on by

Determining the best White cards in a newly released Magic: The Gathering (MTG) set involves analyzing multiple aspects, from card synergy to versatility in various formats. In my usual routine, I regularly checked the list of card spoilers for potential new cards or reprinted ones in comparison to their playability in various existing deck archetypes in the format like Standard or Pioneer.  

Here’s a structured approach to evaluate and identify the top white cards in a new set:

1. Evaluate Card Strength and Efficiency

  • Mana Cost vs. Impact: Look for white cards that provide strong value relative to their mana cost. Cards with efficient mana cost that deliver significant impact on the board are typically strong in both the early and late stages of a game. For example, white one-drops with powerful effects or versatile two-mana removal spells often become staples.
  • Power and Toughness Ratios: For creatures, compare power and toughness with the mana cost. White is known for creatures with efficient stats or beneficial abilities that make them resilient in combat.
  • Ability Value: Cards with keywords like Lifelink, Vigilance, and Flying are often valuable because these abilities work well in both offensive and defensive strategies.

2. Assess Synergy with Existing Deck Archetypes

  • Evaluate Archetype Fit: Consider how well a new card fits into current white archetypes, like Lifegain, Control, or Tokens. For example, a card that creates tokens could synergize well with white token-focused decks, while a board wipe effect might be more useful in control decks.
  • Synergy with Popular Colors: White cards are often paired with blue for control or green for midrange strategies. Consider cards that complement popular color pairs (e.g., Azorius, Selesnya) and whether they enhance or enable powerful synergies.
  • Potential for New Archetypes: Some cards can also inspire or revive archetypes by providing a unique or powerful effect. A new lifegain enabler, for example, could breathe life into a mono-white lifegain strategy or a Selesnya lifegain deck.

3. Examine Versatility Across Different Formats

  • Standard Relevance: Assess if the card is competitive in Standard, where power levels are often lower and synergy with recent sets is key. Cards that provide removal, efficient creatures, or board wipes are generally valued in Standard.
  • Commander Potential: Commander is a format where impactful, splashy, and unique effects tend to shine. Look for white cards with abilities that are impactful in multiplayer settings, such as cards that affect multiple players, protect permanents, or offer powerful scaling effects.
  • Modern and Legacy Viability: In Modern and Legacy, mana efficiency and immediate impact are crucial, as these formats are faster-paced and have access to powerful spells. White cards that offer unconditionally strong effects, like Path to Exile or Rest in Peace, tend to be valued here.

4. Consider Playtesting and Community Feedback

  • Pro Player and Content Creator Reviews: Often, MTG pros and content creators provide early reviews or playtesting insights. Watching or reading set reviews can provide a sense of which cards are gaining traction in different formats and why.
  • Online Communities and Forums: Check Reddit, MTG-specific sites, and online forums where players discuss new cards’ performances. Seeing how other players are utilizing new cards or observing successful decklists can give valuable insight into which cards are exceeding initial expectations.

5. Evaluate Card Flexibility and Resilience

  • Modal or Flexible Cards: Cards with multiple options or choices, such as Prismatic Ending or cards with Adventure or Escalate, are often valuable because they can adapt to different situations. Modal spells are typically worth a close look, as they increase the deck’s overall resilience and adaptability.
  • Resilience to Removal: Evaluate how easily the card can be removed or nullified. Cards with built-in protection (Indestructible, Hexproof) or that generate additional value upon entering the battlefield are often more resilient and effective in games with heavy interaction.

6. Analyze New and Unique Effects

  • Look for Unique Mechanics or Abilities: New mechanics introduced in each set can bring unique and game-changing effects. For instance, mechanics like Enlist, Venture into the Dungeon, or Poison Counters have created entirely new strategies in Standard and beyond.
  • Powerful Recurring Effects: White cards with repeatable or scalable effects are often highly valuable. For instance, enchantments or creatures that provide recurring benefits each turn can become game-defining, especially in Commander and multiplayer formats.

7. Watch for Metagame Shifts and How They Impact White Cards

  • Understand Current Meta Needs: Some white cards become stronger depending on the current metagame. For example, if a set includes many powerful artifacts or graveyard synergies, white cards that target these (like Farewell or Containment Priest) become more desirable.
  • Predict New Meta Shifts: Pay attention to new mechanics or themes in the set, as they might signal upcoming metagame trends. If the new set supports faster creature strategies, efficient white removals like Portable Hole or Swords to Plowshares may become more relevant.

8. Identify Cards with Long-Term Potential

  • Staples for Eternal Formats: Certain white cards with universal utility (like Path to Exile or Teferi’s Protection) often have long-lasting relevance in multiple formats. Look for cards that perform fundamental roles, like efficient removal or lifegain, as these have staying power.
  • Unique Commander Appeal: In the Commander format, white cards that provide strong protection or interaction (e.g., Smothering Tithe, Esper Sentinel) often become format staples because they offer powerful or unique effects that impact multiplayer games significantly.
  • Reprint and Investment Potential: Some white cards gain value due to limited reprints or because they perform essential roles. Cards with high utility or popularity tend to maintain or grow in value, especially if they have niche but powerful effects or strong thematic resonance.

9. Track Performance in Early Tournaments and Decklists

  • Early Tournament Results: Early tournament results and decklists can help identify emerging white cards that perform well in competitive play. Platforms like MTGGoldfish, MTG Top 8, and Star City Games often showcase winning decklists.
  • Analyze Winning Decks: Pay attention to which white cards appear in winning decks and the roles they play, whether in main decks or sideboards. Cards that frequently appear in winning decklists tend to be powerful or useful in multiple matchups.

Conclusion

Combining these evaluation methods gives a well-rounded perspective on the best White cards in any new MTG set. Whether assessing for a specific format or looking for long-term staples, considering each card’s efficiency, synergy, flexibility, and meta impact can help pinpoint top cards for competitive play or casual enjoyment.