Playstyles of Black and White Colors in Magic: the Gathering

Posted on by

In Magic: The Gathering (MTG), each of the five colors—White, Blue, Black, Red, and Green—has distinct playstyles, strengths, and philosophies. Black and White are often considered opposites in many ways, but they can also complement each other when combined. Let’s dive into the individual playstyles of Black and White in detail:

White’s Playstyle

White is the color of order, community, law, and protection. Its strategies focus on fairness, equality, and imposing rules to ensure balance. White’s playstyle can be categorized into the following themes:

  • Aggro and Swarm Tactics
  • White often excels in aggressive strategies, particularly with small creatures. It utilizes low-cost creatures like Soldiers, Knights, or Humans to flood the battlefield quickly.
  • “Go wide” strategies are a hallmark, where White creates numerous creatures and then buffs them using effects like Anthems (e.g., Glorious Anthem), or spells that increase their power and toughness.
  • Control and Taxation
  • White can play a controlling role, often focusing on “taxing” opponents, which forces them to pay extra mana or life to cast spells or use abilities (e.g., Thalia, Guardian of Thraben).
  • White also relies on stax strategies (using cards like Smothering Tithe or Rule of Law) to slow the game down and create a more restrictive environment, forcing everyone to play by its rules.
  • Life Gain
  • White is strong in life gain mechanics, frequently rewarding players for increasing their life total. Cards like Soul Warden or Heliod, Sun-Crowned generate value as life is gained, enabling powerful synergies with cards that trigger off life gain.
  • White’s lifegain strategies also synergize with powerful “life matters” cards such as Aetherflux Reservoir and Ajani’s Pridemate.
  • Protection and Defense
  • White excels in defensive strategies. It uses protection spells and effects like Circle of Protection or Teferi’s Protection to safeguard creatures, permanents, or players.
  • Board wipes (e.g., Wrath of God and Day of Judgment) are another key element of White’s playstyle, enabling players to reset the board when needed, often after taking an early lead or in response to aggressive opponents.
  • Enchantment and Artifact Synergy
  • White has strong synergy with enchantments and artifacts, with cards like Sigil of the Empty Throne and Smothering Tithe emphasizing its control-oriented, value-based play.
  • It often uses enchantments to lock down opponents’ creatures (e.g., Oblivion Ring) or gain incremental advantages (e.g., Banishing Light).

Black’s Playstyle

Black is the color of power, ambition, death, and sacrifice. It is willing to do anything—sometimes at great personal cost—to win. Black’s playstyle emphasizes control over life and death, resource manipulation, and long-term strategies of attrition and card advantage.

  • Resource Manipulation (Life, Cards, and Creatures)
  • Black thrives on manipulating resources—its own and its opponents’. Black is willing to sacrifice life (e.g., Phyrexian Arena, Dark Confidant) or creatures (e.g., Grave Pact, Doomed Necromancer) to gain a significant advantage.
  • Cards like Sign in Blood and Necropotence allow Black to trade life for an extra card draw, gaining more options and extending its reach.
  • Removal and Destruction
  • Black is the best at destroying creatures and other permanents. It has access to a wide array of targeted removal (e.g., Murder, Fatal Push) and board wipes (e.g., Damnation, Toxic Deluge).
  • Black is also known for its ability to force sacrifices (e.g., Diabolic Edict) and discard (e.g., Thoughtseize, Inquisition of Kozilek), further disrupting an opponent’s resources.
  • Graveyard Interaction
  • Black has unmatched graveyard synergy. It can return creatures to play from the graveyard (e.g., Reanimate, Animate Dead), making death less permanent for Black decks. This makes Black incredibly resilient.
  • Sacrifice mechanics are crucial, as Black frequently sacrifices creatures for value and then brings them back, creating endless cycles of recursion (e.g., Sheoldred, Whispering One).
  • Aggression Through Evasion
  • Black’s aggressive creatures often come with evasive abilities like flying, menace, or death touch, making them difficult to block or deal with.
  • Many of its creatures are powerful but fragile, requiring sacrifices or loss of life but dealing significant damage, such as Phyrexian Obliterator or Bloodghast.
  • Ambition and Power at a Cost
  • Black is the color of ambition and is willing to pay the price to win. Cards like Ad Nauseam or Dark Ritual exemplify Black’s willingness to trade immediate costs (life or mana) for overwhelming advantages, giving it explosive, high-risk plays.
  • It also taps into powerful demons and undead armies as themes, using their strength at the cost of sacrifice or pain.

Differences and Synergies Between Black and White

While Black and White have very different philosophies, they also have complementary strategies, which is why their combination in Orzhov (Black/White) decks is popular.

  • Differences:
  • White values community, protection, and equality, whereas Black prioritizes personal gain, ruthlessness, and control over life and death.
  • White often thrives on fair play, ensuring balance and order, while Black seeks to break those balances, bending or breaking the rules to win.
  • Synergies:
  • Both colors share themes like life manipulation (White gains life, while Black can use it as a resource) and control strategies (White taxes, while Black removes threats).
  • Together in Orzhov, they can create powerful decks based around life gain and drain, sacrifice mechanics, and graveyard recursion, creating a balance between Black’s ruthlessness and White’s defensive control. Cards like Teysa Karlov and Vindicate embody the dual nature of Black and White working in harmony.

Conclusion

In Magic: The Gathering, Black and White colors offer contrasting but deeply strategic playstyles. White focuses on creating order, fairness, and unity with a balance between aggression and protection, while Black thrives on power, sacrifice, and resource manipulation. Understanding these differences allows players to harness their individual strengths or combine them into a synergistic, deadly combination in Orzhov decks.